In the midst of the fallout from the most recent FIFA scandal, Qatar
once again finds itself under a microscope. Allegations of bribery and
continued human labor abuses in Qatar have dominated international headlines. I
won’t go into my own views on FIFA and the 2022 World Cup, although I will say
that if an organization (FIFA) puts an event up for sale and it is paid for I
blame the seller not the buyer. I would rather discuss what it is like to live
in Qatar, a place often criticized.
A recent article entitled “The Moral Conflict of Living and Working in
Qatar” has generated a lot of discussion within the expat community here in
Qatar. It can be found in full here:
(Please read it in full before reading my comments because it would
lose context)
The more time I spend thinking about this article, the more
thoughts I have. I commend the author for sparking conversation that I think
doesn’t happen enough for expats in Qatar, doing real critical reflection about
what it means to be here and why they are here in the first place. A lot of
what is in the article resonated with me, not to mention the author is a twenty
something year old, American male, who worked in education in Qatar for three
years. On the whole I can’t say that I disagree with the article. It brings up
many valid points and eloquently captures some of the everyday things that
happen here. What I think it lacks to capture is the complexity of the place
that is Qatar.
First off, as an expat we are a guest in this country. We
are invited in to help support the vision that the country has. Whether you
want to be part of that or not is a personal choice. As a guest we will often
not understand the full picture of what is happening in the country so it is
important to hold judgment as we get only one piece of the story. I think too
often expats, specifically western expats, are critical about what is happening
in Qatar as it is an easy target. We are not here to “fix” it and we are not
here to “enlighten” people but more to provide support where needed. If we want
to “fix” things we should stay in our home countries because there is plenty of
work to do there too.
Now some could say I “drank the karak” in terms of my views
on Qatar because I tend to give it the benefit of the doubt. Friends will often
make fun of me for how highly of a regard I have for Qatar. When it comes down
to it, Qatar is a brand new country and society. It has not had the benefit of
hundreds of years to develop its own practices and identities, yet it is held
to the same global standards of countries like the USA and UK. Many of Qatar’s
challenges are not only its own, for example human labor issues that are
rampant throughout the GCC and have roots in the home countries of many of
these workers. This is not to make an excuse that we shouldn’t be better, we
should. But it is complicated.
I believe that Qatar is a change agent but change also takes
time especially when it is cultural. While yes, we have not seen the
progressive labor changes that we would like recently but this should not come
as a surprise. Qatari cultural is conservative and slow to change. While there
are many great Qatari leaders who are champions for change, getting buy in from
the local community takes painstakingly long.
As far as the impact on expats who live and work here. The
reality is, your sense of “normal” does get skewed. You do get used to a lavish
lifestyle you didn’t know existed before, you do get used to jet setting to a
new country every month, you do get used to driving past abuses on a regular
basis, you do get used to tax free incomes that are staggering compared to your
earning power at home, and you do have to make some moral compromises to live
here. Because like it or not, you are part of this system. A system that
benefits you at the expense of others.
When I look around at the world though, I would say that
moral compromise is happening for many of us. No country is perfect and you
will be hard pressed to find a place where you agree with every political view
and event that takes place. But I would say some countries are better at
masking their issues than others. The last line of the article states “the
thing about Qatar though is that it’s everywhere, it’s out in the open, and you
can’t look away.” I really agree with that statement but I think it is a
positive thing. We are trying to solve many of our challenges. And it won’t
happen overnight. But my hope is that the global community keeps pressure on
Qatar to promote positive changes but does so with patience and understanding that
it will take time. And as we work towards the Qatar National Vision 2030 my
hope is that it will build a better Qatar, one that I am proud to help support.